Starmer Faces Backlash Over Palestinian State Recognition Proposal
Keir Starmer, leader of the UK Labour Party, has drawn significant criticism after announcing that the UK would recognize a Palestinian state, contingent on Israel agreeing to a ceasefire in Gaza and supporting a two-state solution—a stance currently rejected by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government.
Critics include Conservative Party members and others who label Starmer’s proposal as a mere symbolic gesture lacking tangible benefits for Palestinians. They argue that such recognition could inadvertently reward Hamas for its aggressive actions against Israel, disincentivizing peace negotiations and the release of hostages. This perspective is particularly echoed by Emily Damari, a British-Israeli hostage of Hamas, who has spoken out against the proposal.
Adding to the contentious debate, a report from the Times highlights legal concerns, with 40 members of the House of Lords warning that Starmer’s pledge could breach international law. They argue that Palestine does not fulfill the necessary criteria for statehood under the Montevideo Convention, which requires a permanent population, defined territory, government, and capacity to engage with other states.
Prominent legal figures, including seven King’s Counsel and former ministers, have signed a letter calling Starmer’s commitment potentially unlawful, suggesting it undermines the UK’s foreign policy rooted in international law.
In defense, Labour’s business minister, Gareth Thomas, asserted that recognizing Palestine aligns with international law, noting that over 140 countries have already made such a recognition, including a recent decision by Canada.
Starmer is set to address the media later today amidst scrutiny and ongoing discussions regarding UK foreign policy and international relations in the context of the ongoing Israel-Palestine conflict.
Source
Photo credit www.theguardian.com
