Title: A Scoop of Similarity: Trader Joe’s and Costco Vanilla Ice Creams May Share a Manufacturer
In the world of frozen desserts, vanilla ice cream remains a perennial favorite. But for fans of Trader Joe’s and Costco, recent speculation suggests that the two retailers’ beloved Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream offerings may come from the same source. Both brands have garnered attention for their rich and creamy textures, leading many consumers to wonder if they come from the same manufacturer.
Reddit threads point to Humboldt Creamery in California as the producer of Costco’s Kirkland Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream, with suggestions that they also supply Trader Joe’s version. While both chains market privately labeled products, it’s plausible that they share this creamery as a supplier.
However, subtle differences do exist between the two ice creams. Many online reviews indicate that Kirkland’s offering boasts a creamy texture paired with a balanced sweetness, while Trader Joe’s French Vanilla has a bolder vanilla flavor profile. A notable distinction lies in their ingredients—the Kirkland version uses pasteurized egg yolks, whereas Trader Joe’s incorporates sugared egg yolks to enhance sweetness. Furthermore, Kirkland utilizes vanilla extract, lending a more subdued flavor, in contrast to Trader Joe’s natural vanilla flavor, which is more pronounced.
Pricing also differs significantly; Kirkland sells its ice cream in a double pack for around $17, while Trader Joe’s offers a single quart for about $4.79. For those seeking value, Kirkland provides a more economical option, while Trader Joe’s suits smaller needs.
Ultimately, both brands exemplify the "super-premium" category, characterized by low air content and high fat, resulting in an exceptionally smooth treat. Whether you’re indulging in a cone or crafting an ice cream cake, one thing is for certain—both offerings cater to ice cream lovers’ cravings.
Source
Note: The image is for illustrative purposes only and is not the original image of the presented article.
